Melting Pot or Civil War?: A Son of Immigrants Makes the Case Against Open Borders

Long before Covid-19 and the death of George Floyd rocked America Reihan Salam predicted our current unrest--and provided a blueprint for reuniting the country. "Tthe years to come may see a new populist revolt driven by the resentments of working-class Americans of color. For too long liberals have suggested that only cruel racist or nativist bigots would want to restrict immigration. Anyone motivated by compassion and egalitarianism would choose open or nearly-open bordersor so the argument goes. Now Reihan Salam the son of Bangladeshi immigrants turns this argument on its head. In this deeply researched but also deeply personal book Salam shows why uncontrolled immigration is bad for everyone including people like his family. Our current system has intensified the isolation of our native poor and risks ghettoizing the children of poor immigrants. It ignores the challenges posed by the declining demand for less-skilled labor even as it exacerbates ethnic inequality and deepens our political divides. If we continue on our current course in which immigration policy serves wealthy insiders who profit from cheap labor and cosmopolitan extremists attack the legitimacy of borders the rise of a new ethnic underclass is inevitable. Even more so than now class politics will be ethnic politics and national unity will be impossible. Salam offers a solution if we have the courage to break with the past and craft an immigration policy that serves our long-term national interests. Rejecting both militant multiculturalism and white identity politics he argues that limiting total immigration and favoring skilled immigrants will combat rising inequality balance diversity with assimilation and foster a new nationalism that puts the interests of all Americansnative-born and foreign-bornfirst.